My mom recently had a bit of an accident involving her knee and some over-enthusiastic chasing of a tennis ball down a court. It went the way knees usually go: first it was quite sore but expected to get better, and the next day it was really sore and the size of a melon. So she went to the orthopaedic surgeon.
There, he diagnosed a haemarthrosis and likely minisceal tear, and booked her in for an arthroscopy the next day. In theatre, he confirmed a tear of one of the meniscii, as well as a tear of one of the cruciate ligaments. He cleaned up and washed out a bit, then popped my mom into a brace, explained her options, and referred her to physio.
Although her knee did well with physio and the pain got a lot better over the next few months, it still felt quite unstable and tended to trouble her on longer walks or excursions. So, she went back to another orthopod (this one a knee specialist), who pencilled her in for another arthroscopy and ligament repair a few weeks later. This operation she had yesterday. It was done under spinal anaesthesia, and my mom could watch the whole thing on a big screen while the surgeon talked her through what he was doing. Today, she's home in bed, injecting her own clexane.
I guess the story isn't too remarkable, if you're the kind of person who's never had to use the public health services in this country. I mean, she had a problem, she went to the doctor, and it was sorted out. Isn't that how it's supposed to be?
It is, but for the vast majority of South Africans, things don't really work like that. We see a lot of knee injuries here in the crater - mostly rugby- and netball-related - and here our options are far more limited. We usually put them in a special bandage called a Robert-Jones for a while, give them a sick note, and some pain-killers. If things still look bad after a few weeks, we send a referral letter via the blood courier to the orthopods in The Valley, and hope for a speedy answer (that is, one that arrives within the week). They'll usually give us a date for their clinic a week or two ahead, and then once the patient is seen there they'll hopefully get squashed onto a scope list within the next month or two.
So, all in all, a woman with my mom's injury presenting to my hospital would have to wait much longer to have it sorted out than my mom did. My mom's medical bills are not negligible, but luckily she has medical aid that will help her with those. A patient presenting in The Crater would pay an arbitrary amount calculated according to how much they earned.
Perhaps to say that in the private sector you pay with your money, and in the public sector you pay with your time is oversimplifying things, but it is partly true. It is possible that in the public sector you sometimes pay with your health as well, but the specialists in the public sector are no less skilled than those in private - they're just less numerous. The higher morbidity in poorer communities is probably a result of complex socioeconomic issues, and not just of limited medical staff and resources.
With the new National Health Insurance plan, the government is hoping to make all South Africans pay equally, with a combination of time and money, to receive equal resources. I suppose it's a noble principle in theory, but considering the Department of Health's track record, it's just too terrifying for words. I value my time far more than I value my money, and am eternally grateful that I can choose which one I am going to give away.
Picture Credits